Yamaha, dealer win lawsuit in rollover crash of Rhino
(March 23, 2011) WARREN COUNTY, Ohio (PRNewswire) — In what the trial judge labeled the largest civil trial in the history of the Warren County, Ohio, Court of Common Pleas, an eight-member Ohio jury returned a verdict in favor of Yamaha and its dealer on March 21 in a case involving the death of a 10-year-old girl who was ejected from a Yamaha Rhino in a rollover crash.
Plaintiffs, who sought $20 million in compensatory and punitive damages, alleged that defects in the 2007 Rhino 660 caused the vehicle to overturn, resulting in a fatal head injury to the front seat passenger, Ellie Sand. Plaintiffs claimed that the Rhino lacked adequate stability, a throttle limiting device, and occupant protection features such as doors and different handholds. Additionally, plaintiffs claimed that the warnings provided with the Rhino were insufficient, and that Yamaha made misrepresentations in its marketing and advertising of the Rhino.
Yamaha defended its design, warnings and representations concerning the safe use of the Rhino, and contended that the crash and the decedent's death were caused by reckless operation by an inexperienced 21-year-old driver who attempted to perform a high speed "fishtail" stunt maneuver in a dark, muddy cornfield with four unbelted and unhelmeted child passengers in the two-person vehicle.
Yamaha's crash reconstruction established that the driver's high speed turning maneuver caused the Rhino's tires to furrow into the muddy field, tripping the vehicle and ejecting Ellie Sand, who was not wearing a seat belt.
Yamaha Rhino
While it was undisputed by the parties that the decedent was not wearing a helmet and that her fatal head injury occurred when the roll cage landed on her head, plaintiffs claimed that she was wearing a seatbelt at the time of the crash. Additionally, plaintiffs denied that the crash occurred at high speed, instead contending that the vehicle rolled over at a speed as low as 11 mph.
After a three week trial involving testimony from 41 witnesses, the jury returned a complete defense verdict in favor of Yamaha, its dealer who sold the vehicle and one of the vehicle's co-owners who was also a defendant.
In rejecting plaintiffs' claims against Yamaha, the jury also found that decedent's death was proximately caused by the negligence of the driver, the decedent's parents and the hosts of the party at which the incident occurred.
Yamaha's lead counsel, Paul Cereghini, of the national product liability defense firm, Bowman and Brooke LLP commented on the verdict:
"We are pleased that the jury, after hearing all of the evidence, rejected plaintiffs' claims and found that neither Yamaha nor the Rhino vehicle caused this tragic event. This is now the fifth defense verdict in a row for Yamaha. The Rhino is a safe and defect free vehicle, and these verdicts demonstrate that Yamaha can and will successfully defend this fine product."